I think any kind of ornament/momento would be fine. Just thought
the ornaments with some of his "cool gigs" might be fun down the
road for him....It could be as simple as writing "Jay Leno-Tonight
Show 2005" on a store bought inexpensive ornament. Not meant to
bring on stress, craft anxiety

, etc.
I don't think we should do baked goods-we have no idea how long it
will take to get to him,etc. Let's keep it simple
Amy, those are cute ornaments!

Amy..youre really confirming HOW MUCH I want to MOVE TO ME!!!!!!! (or MA!!)...the ornaments are very cute...everytime I go to Ellsworth, I go to the Christmas Store on Rt. Somethingorother (cant remember) and browse and pick an ornament made by a local artist.
Liz--this is easy enough...I think I can get something done--remember, my girls are elementary school aged w/MANY teachers and Ive always got to come up with teacher gift ideas--so this is kinda the same thing because the kids always make gifts for the teachers--handmade gifts are nice as the stand out and hopefully the teachers will remember who gave it to them.
I agree w/Lori that we should send him a NESP ornament cuz theyre so purdy!!

I will make something! I just have to think of a date he appeared! Maybe Rockefellor Center 2006.
OK I just made something. All I need is an appearance to put on it.
Since this is from NESP why don't you use one of the New England tour dates that you went to? The Big E?
you can include me on something. I'll get it done this weekend & post a pic of it. Not sure what appearance I'll do, maybe The View when he did that incredible version of TRP.
Browsing through Christmas Tree this morning and spotted a few things for our crafty NESP'ers
1) Photo ornaments frames; just put in a photo. Comes in red or green or gold with ribbon to attach to the tree. Easy enough for even me to do....if only I could think of a good photo to put in the frame.
2) Blank balls

clear balls

white balls

OK...balls all ready to be hand crafted

decorated
Box of 4 $1.69 Could not think of what I could do to those so I left them on the shelf. Several boxes of them....
OH I may just have thought of a photo....

Find a good one of him on the NESP stool grimsby

Find a good one of him on the NESP stool grimsby

Will you stop reading my mind 
Yes, I'll do that. Taylor & his stool which is probably better for me than playing with Taylor & his clean white balls.....although......