I think that David C. has a very smug attitude, but GOD he was GREAT last nite! And if I am honest, he is GREAT, most the time. Loved HELLO!!!
I wasn't as moved this week by Jason A. as I was by Imagine, but it was still very good and I still love him
David H- I don't care what the heck he did for a job before he got involved with Idol,I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this song and he did a GREAT job on it!!!
Jason C.- He is really talented-loved it and had also never heard it before
Michael is one of my faves but just wasn't thrilled with his performance
Luke-bad song choice in my opinion, but I like him, I hope he stays
Danny- Well, he's just a kid,(so he keeps reminding us with his text message talk,)but I'm ready for him to go home
Chicizie-I thought he did much better last week, but I just don't think he's as good as most of the other guys
I am so over Danny sassing Simon every night.....WHATEVER!
I really like Michael's voice but hate the way he moves....too stiff!
David H. is very talented but I hate the way he eye f**ks the camera every week...yuk.
Let's face it, there are lots of talented performers out there but there will never be another Taylor Hicks and IMO that's a good thing! I need a concert fix something awful! Enough of winter. Enough of blah. Bring on some live soul music complete with harp and REAL dancing. Please!
I am so over Danny sassing Simon every night.....WHATEVER!
I really like Michael's voice but hate the way he moves....too stiff!
David H. is very talented but I hate the way he eye f**ks the camera every week...yuk.
Let's face it, there are lots of talented performers out there but there will never be another Taylor Hicks and IMO that's a good thing! I need a concert fix something awful! Enough of winter. Enough of blah. Bring on some live soul music complete with harp and REAL dancing. Please!
I second that motion.......
Underwhelmed is my word for the night.
Top 2 - Carly & Brooke
Put the others in a paper bag, shake it up and the 2 that fall out can go home.
B-O-R-I-N-G
I was expecting a little bit more from the decade that molded me.
Don't shoot me but I think Amanda did very well with the Joan Jett number. Her fiance is a looker.
Brooke picked the best song and I loved it acoustic but I do not love her voice....kinda weak IMO.
Carly deserves to win for the girls but a boy will win I think. Hope it's a boy/boy finale....first since season two!!
I am waiting to download Hello from David Cook .....they are up on iTunes (pics and song title) but "not available" pops up....I think they'll be ready in the AM.
Loved Carly(as always), and I surprised myself-I loved Amanda!!!! That song was PERFECT for her! As soon as I heard it start up I knew she was going to do a great job!
My better half (Bob) thought Brooke was great. He loved that her performance was vocally driven. I wasn't quite as impressed, but I DO love Brooke!
Before you download from iTunes, check
http://www.rickey.org. I am 99% sure you can get it from there for free.
That's where I got my Taylor mp3s during AI5 and I know he carries all of them.
I can't get behind Amanda. I don't think she can sing - she screams really well but singing? No.
I love the slight raspy tone that Brooke has and Margaux had a good comment tonight - would love to see what Brooke & Jason might be able to do together on tour. Musically very interesting! To me, she's the girl's answer to Jason Castro.
If Brooke and Jason make the top ten, they could be paired together on the AI tour for an acoustic duet!
Amanda rocked last nite I actually moved my foot to her last night.
Brooke did ok her vocals seemed weak to me though,still she is the only one I MIGHT buy a cd of along with Jason Castro. All the others I just don't care about.I think Carley and Micheal are plants I feel they have are really been given the big chances to make it big with the exception of having a huge audience exposure.
I think Amanda rocked the house last night.She used her voice perfectly,didn't scream and it made a huge difference in my opinion of her ! She can really belt out a tune and I love that she is so different from the rest.